Somebody is forwarding their work email to a personal account. Here is how to find out who
- Technology
- IT consultancy
- Microsoft 365
- Cyber security
- Knutsford
Most firms find out by accident. Somebody leaves, their mailbox gets tidied up, and there in the rules is a line that has been quietly copying every message to a personal address for the last two years.
The first instinct is that this was done to them. It almost never was. What normally happened is that somebody needed to answer a client on a Sunday evening, could not get into their mail from the laptop at home, went looking in the settings, found a box that said forward a copy, and solved their own problem in about forty seconds.
They were being conscientious. That is the awkward part.
What the firm has, once that box is ticked
An unknown quantity of client correspondence now sits in a mailbox you do not control. You cannot back it up, and you cannot search it when a subject access request lands and asks for everything you hold on somebody. You cannot close it on the day that person leaves, because it was never yours to close. If their personal account is reused on a shared family tablet, that is now part of your filing system too.
None of that depends on the member of staff being careless with it. The access simply is not yours to govern.
Find out before you change anything
The number is almost never nought, and most firms have never looked.
In Microsoft 365, the Exchange admin centre carries an Auto forwarded messages report, which shows messages automatically forwarded out of your organisation to recipients in external domains, and names the account doing the forwarding. It opens on the last seven days. The summary will go back as far as ninety.
Two details decide whether you read it correctly.
It reports activity rather than configuration. A rule that exists but has forwarded nothing this week will not appear in a seven-day view, so widen the window before you conclude the answer is none. And internal forwarding is a different thing entirely, untouched by the controls below, which is usually fine and occasionally not.
There are also two mechanisms that produce the same outcome. One is an Inbox rule, set by the user. The other is mailbox forwarding, sometimes called SMTP forwarding, which an administrator sets on the mailbox itself and which the user cannot see at all. If you are taking over an estate from another provider, check the second kind too. Nobody ever leaves a note.
The setting whose default nobody can state
Here is where it gets genuinely strange, and it is worth knowing before you tell a client or an insurer that you block this.
External forwarding is governed by the outbound spam filter policy, which offers three values: on, off, and Automatic - System-controlled, which is the default. Microsoft's own documentation explains that when the automatic value was introduced it was equivalent to on. In 2021 it changed to off, but only for new organisations and for existing ones that were not actively using the automatic setting. For organisations already using it, Microsoft says it can remain equivalent to on.
So the honest answer to "does your tenant allow staff to forward their mail out of the business" is, for a great many firms, that it depends which year the tenant was created and what somebody did or did not touch five years ago.
Because the behavior can differ by organization, configure On - Forwarding is enabled or Off - Forwarding is disabled instead of Automatic - System-controlled.
Take the advice. Set it explicitly, in either direction, so the setting says what you mean rather than what the tenant inherited. When forwarding is blocked, the sender gets a bounce that reads 5.7.520 Access denied, Your organization does not allow external forwarding, which is at least a message somebody can bring to you rather than a silent failure.
Now the part most advice skips
Delete the rules, switch forwarding off, and you have not finished. You have removed the workaround while leaving the problem that produced it.
The person still cannot get at their mail from home on a Sunday. So the next version is worse: the mailbox added by hand to a personal phone that nobody manages, or client documents sent out as attachments one at a time, or photographs of the screen. Each of those is harder to find than a forwarding rule, and a forwarding rule at least shows up in a report.
- 01Pull the report over ninety days, and check mailbox-level forwarding as well as Inbox rules
- 02Ask each person what they were trying to do, before anything is deleted
- 03Fix that: mail that works properly on their phone and in a browser, signed in as them
- 04Then remove the rules, set the forwarding policy explicitly, and alert on new rules being created
Step three is the one that makes the rest stick, and it is usually not difficult. Mail in a browser and a managed app on the phone covers almost every case we are shown. What it needs is somebody to have set it up and told them it exists, which is the bit that gets skipped when a laptop is handed over at nine in the morning on somebody's first day.
Is it a breach
People want a yes or a no here, and it would be dishonest to give one.
The ICO defines a personal data breach as "a breach of security leading to the accidental or unlawful destruction, loss, alteration, unauthorised disclosure of, or access to, personal data". On reporting, its wording is that you establish the likelihood of the risk to people's rights and freedoms: if a risk is likely you must notify, and if it is unlikely you do not have to. That is a judgement about particular facts, which means the volume, the kind of data, how long it ran and who could reach that personal account. A blog post cannot make it for you, and anyone who tells you confidently either way has not asked what was in the mail.
One distinction matters more than the reporting question. If the person whose mailbox it is did not create that rule, you are not looking at a workaround, you are looking at the aftermath of somebody else getting in. That is a different afternoon entirely, and we have written about how they get in even where multi-factor authentication was on. Ask the owner of the mailbox before you assume which of the two you have.
If you would like somebody to pull the report and tell you what is in it, that is a short conversation. It is a better one to have on a Tuesday than during a subject access request.
We work with businesses across Knutsford, Alderley Edge, Wilmslow, Altrincham, Stockport and Warrington, and remotely for clients anywhere in the UK.
If any of this sounds like your business, we will tell you plainly whether we can help.
